John Marshall Harlan: Great Dissenter of the Warren Court by Tinsley E. Yarbrough

By Tinsley E. Yarbrough

Whilst David Souter was once nominated by means of President Bush to the best courtroom, he stated John Marshall Harlan as his version. It was once a fascinating selection. fashionable by means of conservatives and deeply revered by means of his liberal brethren, Harlan was once a guy, as Justice William Brennan lamented, whose "massive scholarship" hasn't ever been totally well-known. furthermore, he was once the second one Harlan to take a seat at the courtroom, following his grandfather--also named John Marshall Harlan. yet whereas his grandfather was once an outspoken supporter of reconstruction on a conservative courtroom, the more youthful Harlan emerged as a critic of the Warren Court's liberal growth of civil liberties.
Now, within the first biography of this significant yet overlooked jurist, Tinsley Yarbrough presents an in depth account of Harlan's existence, from his privileged adolescence to his retirement and loss of life. Yarbrough examines the forces and occasions which formed the Justice's jurisprudence--his adolescence and infrequently advanced kin relationships, schooling at Princeton and Oxford, his paintings as a prosecutor in the course of Prohibition, Republican social gathering actions, wartime provider within the military Air strength, and years as one of many nation's preeminent company attorneys (a profession culminating in his safeguard of the du Pont brothers within the mammoth DuPont-GM antitrust suit). The e-book focuses, besides the fact that, on Harlan's years at the excessive bench. Yarbrough weaves jointly discussions of the Justice's relatives along with his brethren, clerks, and employees, an exam of Harlan's function within the decision-making procedure at the court docket, and an research of his jurisprudence. The Justice's method of constitutional interpretation exalted precedent, deference to governmental energy, and slim judgements heavily tied to case evidence; yet he additionally authorised an evolving, inventive version of constitutional development which accredited expansive readings of constitutional rights. Yarbrough's info Harlan's shut courting with Justice Frankfurter, displaying how--despite their friendship and alliance--Harlan strongly marked out his personal place, either for my part and judicially, at the Warren and Burger courts. And he examines the substance and value of his dissents in such recognized situations as Miranda and the Pentagon Papers.
Intensively researched, easily written, and incisively argued, Yarbrough's biography deals an soaking up account of the existence and occupation of a superb dissenter, hailed via admirers as a "lawyer's legal professional" and a "judge's judge." Coming at a time while the excessive court docket has began to undertake a lot of Harlan's ideas, this account presents a vital standpoint at the court docket, civil liberties, and a pivotal determine within the historical past of both.

Show description

Read Online or Download John Marshall Harlan: Great Dissenter of the Warren Court PDF

Best professionals & academics books

Andre Green at the Squiggle Foundation

Regardless of being one of many most efficient psychoanalysts operating this day, a lot of Green's paintings has until eventually lately been unavailable in English. This paintings rectifies this by means of accumulating jointly 5 lectures given to the Squiggle origin in London. This available and obviously written ebook offers a distinct advent to Green's paintings and its relation to the paintings of D.

Daniel Defoe: Master of Fictions: His Life and Ideas

Daniel Defoe led an exhilarating and certainly precarious lifestyles. A provocative pamphleteer and journalist, a secret agent and double agent, a innovative and a dreamer, he used to be variously hunted through mobs with murderous reason and handled as a star through the main strong leaders of the rustic. Imprisoned again and again, pilloried and reviled via his enemies, via all of it he controlled to supply the most major literature of the eighteenth century.

Albert Schweitzer : a biography

This biography presents a flexible perception into the lifestyles, paintings, and considered Albert Schweitzer (1875-1965). Nils Ole Oermann bargains a close account of the multifaceted lifetime of Albert Schweitzer who used to be a theologian, organist, thinker, general practitioner, and scientific missionary. Schweitzer's lifestyles used to be now not a immediately course from the parsonage in Alsace to the college of Strasbourg, then directly to the clinic in Lambarene, and finishing with the Nobel Peace Prize in Oslo.

Additional resources for John Marshall Harlan: Great Dissenter of the Warren Court

Example text

To have entered Buclfner's "Boy Scout" 13 Oxford or Cambridge without any special preparation. With five years further intellectual work, he should ... 29 His other references were equally glowing, and in 1920, his last year at Princeton, Harlan became a Rhodes Scholar and began a three-year course of study in law and jurisprudence at Oxford's Balliol College, the university's law school. Harlan's years at Oxford confirmed the high regard for things British he had begun to acquire at Appleby. The British insistence on form and structure for their own sake both annoyed and amused him, but later descriptions of him as an Anglophile were essentially accurate.

And found that we [two] were marching majestically down Fifth Avenue while the entire battalion had gone the other way, including the band. . 28 His bandsmanship notwithstanding, Harlan's record at Princeton placed him in contention for a Rhodes Scholarship at Oxford University. H. Guest, his Appleby headmaster, wrote Princeton's Rhodes committee: I do not think . . that of all the boys who have passed through my hands, I could name one who fulfills more completely the requirements called for by the conditions of the Rhodes Trust, than John Harlan.

When he was in high school, the family lived in Nebraska. One day Buckner's father suggested that Emory take a course in shorthand during the summer at a business college. After completing such a course, his father explained, a friend's son had secured a position as a stenographer earning $80 a month, a handsome sum in those days. Emory took his father's advice and after high school also attended a teacher's institute. Following a year teaching eighth-grade classes in Oklahoma territory, he drew on his shorthand training to become court reporter for the chief justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.37 of 5 – based on 36 votes