Democracy, Religious Pluralism and the Liberal Dilemma of by Monica Mookherjee

By Monica Mookherjee

How should still liberal democratic governments reply to voters as spiritual believers whose values, norms and practices could lie open air the cultural mainstream? the most demanding political questions bobbing up this present day concentrate on the adequacy of a coverage of ‘live and allow dwell’ liberal toleration in contexts the place disputes in regards to the metaphysical fact of conflicting world-views abound. Does liberal toleration fail to offer all electorate their due? Do voters of religion deserve a much better kind of lodging from the nation within the kind of ‘recognition’? This factor is much from settled. Controversies over the phrases of non secular lodging proceed to dominate political agendas all over the world.

This is the 1st edited assortment to supply a sustained exam of the politics of toleration and popularity in an age of non secular pluralism. The aftermath of the occasions of September eleven, 2001 have dramatised the urgency of this debate. It has additionally surfaced, nationally and globally, in disputes approximately terrorism, safeguard and gender and human rights questions on the subject of minority groups. This quantity brings jointly a gaggle of recent and demonstrated students from the fields of legislations and philosophy, who all current clean and difficult views on an pressing debate. will probably be essential studying for complicated researchers in political and criminal philosophy, non secular and cultural reports and comparable disciplines.

“This well timed quantity contains essays exploring a far under-examined element of latest debates approximately multiculturalism, particularly, the problem of non secular pluralism. Wide-ranging, nuanced, and illuminating, the chapters absorb such very important subject matters because the courting among spiritual toleration and the politics of popularity; among non secular teams and minority cultures; and among spiritual pluralism and regulations of multiculturalism. The members usefully draw on contemporary examples of dilemmas of non secular tolerance and intolerance in liberal democratic states, and a number of other ask concerning the interface of legislation and non secular practices. This assortment displays the easiest of present serious brooding about the moral, felony, and political dimensions of spiritual pluralism in various liberal societies that democratic thought has to offer.”

Monique Deveaux
Political technology Department
William College

“The quantity makes an important contribution to debates approximately faith in political conception. starting with the options of tolerance and lodging, the authors significantly check key conceptual instruments utilized by liberal democracies to handle spiritual range. the result's a chain of essays that comprehensively deal with probably the most urgent concerns in modern society. This quantity methods spiritual range in a uniquely complicated and coherent manner.”

“Exploring a variety of material in wealthy theoretical context, the authors ponder such matters as polygamy, shari’a, non secular autonomy, multiculturalism, and secularism”

Lori Beaman division of Classics and spiritual Studies
University of Ottawa

Show description

Read or Download Democracy, Religious Pluralism and the Liberal Dilemma of Accommodation PDF

Similar ethics books

The Elements of Justice

What's justice? Questions of justice are questions on what everyone is due, yet what that implies in perform is determined by context. counting on context, the formal query of what individuals are due is responded by means of rules of barren region, reciprocity, equality, or desire. Justice, hence, is a constellation of parts that express a level of integration and cohesion, however the integrity of justice is proscribed, in a fashion that's comparable to the integrity of a local instead of that of a construction.

The Ethics of Immigration

Within the Ethics of Immigration, Joseph Carens synthesizes a life of paintings to discover and light up essentially the most urgent problems with our time. Immigration poses functional difficulties for western democracies and likewise demanding situations the ways that humans in democracies take into consideration citizenship and belonging, approximately rights and obligations, and approximately freedom and equality.

The African American Challenge to Just War Theory: A Christian Approach

During this leading edge therapy of the ethics of battle, Ryan P. Cumming brings classical assets of simply conflict conception into dialog with African American voices. the result's a brand new path in exactly battle proposal that demanding situations dominant interpretations of simply warfare thought by means of trying to the views of these at the underside of historical past and politics.

Additional resources for Democracy, Religious Pluralism and the Liberal Dilemma of Accommodation

Sample text

These institutions had to un-learn, or rephrase (secularize or find alternatives to) religious understandings and religious public language’ (quoted from the review). This is indeed so, but ‘secularism’ has not been the only, nor in my view, the right language. 23 See Bader (2007a: 113–117) for a criticism of the unfinished doctrinal learning by many leading philosophers. 24 Habermas also speaks in terms of a learning process: ‘Dieser schmerzhafte Lernprozess steht dem Islam noch bevor. Auch in der islamischen Welt wächst die Einsicht, dass heute ein historischhermeneutischer Zugang zu den Lehren des Koran nötig is.

Or they developed denominational truths compatible with democracy, so that the two could not come into conflict. Protestant religions are made compatible (and monotheistic religions and aggressive Enlightenment secularism are most certainly amongst them). So one has to specify the terminus ad quem of ‘learning’. Learning ‘minimal morality’ is less prone to be accused of imposing ‘Western Imperialism’ via the backdoor (see Bader 2007a: Chapter 2 on moderate universalism, moral minimalism and broad and deep intercultural dialogue).

The leaders of Catholic parties formed important counter-elites against clerical elites, and, eventually, Catholic parties became increasingly more independent from the Church. The original political project was fundamentalist and openly theocratic, intransigent, integralist, and intolerant. As Kalyvas explains: Naturally, such an ideology lends itself easily to theorizing about the antithetical relationship of religion (particularly Catholicism) and democracy. Indeed, it has been repeatedly argued that the “injection of religion into political controversies tends to hamper working out the pragmatic accommodations needed by a functioning democracy” (Reichley); that Catholicism “was associated with the absence of democracy or with limited or late democratic development” (Huntington 1993); and that it “appeared antithetical to democracy in pre-World-War II Europe” (Lipset et al).

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.46 of 5 – based on 8 votes